Grid constraints: a double hit to BSUoS and the CfD Supplier Obligation levy
Grid constraints are driving balancing costs higher, but their impact doesn’t stop at BSUoS. Retail Pricing Lead Rob Taylor explores the wider effect on the CfD Supplier Obligation levy and what this could mean for business energy costs.
Balancing Services Use of System (BSUoS) charges are back in the spotlight. NESO's draft tariffs for April 2027 point to a jump of almost 60% on this year, and its latest indicative forecast suggests closer to double, largely to recover costs it under-forecast in 2026.
The main driver is grid constraints: the cost of managing a network that can't always move power from where it's generated to where it's used. But the effect doesn't stop at BSUoS. When constrained wind farms hold Contracts for Difference (CfDs), switching them off also changes what flows through the CfD Supplier Obligation Levy.
For businesses both costs end up on the bill.
BSUoS: costs running far ahead of forecast
BSUoS recovers what NESO spends balancing the system. Since April 2023 it has been a fixed tariff, set in advance based on NESO's forecast of costs. When actual costs come in higher, the shortfall is carried forward and added to future tariffs.
In 2026 that gap has been large. From April to September, balancing costs came to around £1.63bn against NESO's original forecast of £1.28bn, an overspend of about 27%. September ran at more than double the forecast. October was higher still: £678m against a forecast of £292m, the most expensive month in at least two years.
The result shows up in next year's tariffs. NESO's draft tariffs, published in September, rise from £13.74/MWh to £21.67/MWh for April–September 2027, and from £12.49/MWh to £18.42/MWh for October 2027–March 2028. NESO's November forecast has since raised its indicative tariffs further, to £27.06/MWh and £21.45/MWh, as the forecast under-recovery to March 2027 grew from £1,062m to £1,599m. Final tariffs are due in December.
Why costs have risen: it's mostly constraints
Around nine in every ten pounds NESO spends on balancing goes on constraints. Reserve, frequency response and energy imbalance make up the rest, and they have stayed broadly in line with expectations.
Constraint costs arise when the network can't carry power from where it's generated to where it's needed. The good example is wind generation in Scotland: when it's windy, more power is available than the lines south can carry, so NESO pays some wind farms to turn down and pays other generators, further south, to turn up.
Three things have pushed those costs up this year:
- Higher wholesale prices. Day-ahead power averaged around £134/MWh in September and £145/MWh in October, roughly double a year earlier. Replacement power is bought at prices linked to that market.
- Less network capacity. Planned outages, needed to maintain and upgrade the grid, have cut how much power key boundaries can carry. On some days the Scotland–England boundary has been running at around half its capacity.
- A premium for location. NESO can't buy replacement power from just anywhere: it has to come from the right side of a full boundary. With fewer options to choose from, it pays more. In October, thermal constraint actions cost around £339/MWh, about 2.3 times the average day-ahead price of £145/MWh, one of the highest ratios in more than two years.
Thermal constraints: rising prices, not just rising volumes
Thermal constraints, where power physically can't flow across a full boundary, are by far the largest part of constraint costs. In October alone they topped £600m.
The striking finding is that this year's rise is driven more by price than by volume. In September 2026, thermal constraint costs were £274m higher than a year earlier. Around £70m of that came from NESO constraining more power. The other £204m came from paying more for each MWh: the average cost rose from about £147/MWh to £260/MWh.
It also matters which side of a constraint the money goes on. Every constraint has two legs: wind turned down behind the boundary, and replacement power turned up on the other side. In October, NESO turned down around 2,000 GWh of wind. Paying those wind farms to turn down cost about £52m. Most of the £600m+ went on the second leg, buying replacement power on the other side of full boundaries, from gas plants, storage and interconnector imports.
Turning down wind is the cheap part of the bill. Replacing it is where the cost sits.
The hidden cost: lost CfD paybacks
The impact of constraints doesn’t end with BSUoS. They can also affect another part of the business energy bill, the CfD Supplier Obligation levy.
CfDs pay generators the difference between a fixed strike price and the market price. When the market is below the strike, the generator is topped up. When the market is above it, the generator pays the difference back. Those payments flow through the CfD Supplier Obligation levy, which suppliers pay and pass on to customers.
At today's prices, many newer offshore wind farms have strike prices well below the market. Prices sometimes dip below the strike, but in the current market these farms pay back far more than they receive over the course of a month, and that payback lowers the levy. When NESO turns one of them down to manage a constraint, the power isn't generated and the payback is lost.
In October, NESO turned down around 531 GWh of wind with active CfDs. The estimated cost is around £9m in lost CfD paybacks: about £17m of paybacks lost on low-strike farms, partly offset by £8m of top-ups avoided on older, high-strike contracts.
An example of an offshore wind farm shows how it works. Its strike price is around £82/MWh. When it was turned down in October, the volume-weighted market price averaged £136/MWh. Each MWh it generated would have paid back about £54/MWh. When turned down, it paid NESO about £26/MWh, so NESO received something, but the CfD scheme lost a payback twice as large.
Spread across the electricity demand the levy is charged on, that £9m adds £0.43/MWh to the levy for October. LCCC's net payments to CfD generators that month came to around £94m (see notes), so lost paybacks added roughly 10% to October's net CfD cost.
What it means for businesses
Constraints hit business electricity costs twice: once through BSUoS, and again, more quietly, through the CfD levy. Neither lands immediately: because BSUoS is a fixed tariff, this year's overspend is recovered through future tariffs, while the CfD Supplier Obligation levy is trued up through reconciliation.
When low-cost CfD wind is switched off, the payback that would have reduced the CfD Supplier Obligation levy is lost too, so both are worth understanding when reviewing non-commodity costs.
How much of these costs reaches a business, and when, depends on how its contract treats non-commodity costs. Either way, they are worth understanding when planning budgets.
Things to watch over the coming months:
- NESO's final BSUoS tariffs for 2027/28, due in December.
- CfD start dates. Several large wind farms hold CfDs that haven't started yet. Once they do, more low-strike CfD wind will sit behind constrained boundaries.
- Network upgrades. New transmission links will ease the biggest constraints, but most are several years away.